Home Tech Support

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Thursday, 22 September 2011

I Met Michael Nielsen!

Posted on 16:50 by Unknown
I did it today! Woot! (And I got a picture with him!) Although he is specifically a physicist, most well known for his seminal textbook on quantum computing, he came to give a colloquium about open science in general, and it's doubly cool for me because I'm interested in both physics and things like open science. (Also, before the talk, I mentioned to him that I first read about him on Glyn Moody's blog, which you should totally read. That's how Dr. Nielsen figured out I'm a free software kind of guy. He also told me that Mr. Moody's a cool guy too.)

He talked about stuff like the development of Linux and Wikipedia through crowdsourcing, but he also discussed failures like the innumerable abandoned technical wikis intended to attract the best researchers in that field that litter the web. He also discussed how scientists' conservatism regarding releasing data openly dates back many centuries, when 200 years after the introduction of the printing press in Europe, scientists in Europe were still reluctant to release their work in print. He took that to today and how that conservatism negatively affects research progress, along with what some people have done to combat it, and in the spirit of the talk, he opened the floor to questions and also to discussion about how individual scientists can promote and do open science.

I was able to ask him a question about one thing he said about Galileo: apparently, Galileo was concerned about other people getting credit for doing the same work as him independently of him, so he only "published" his work by sending a few select other scientists his work, but scrambled into anagrams unreadable at first sight. Then, if those scientists tried to publish similar work independently, he would be able to pull out the unscrambled manuscripts and prove that he came up with those ideas first. I asked him if the scrambling was really done for that purpose, given that Galileo published his work about a heliocentric universe in vernacular Italian, as opposed to the scholarly Latin, specifically to reach the masses (and that's what got him the undue attention of the Roman Catholic Church). Dr. Nielsen replied that while that might be the case, it is clear that his intent with those scrambled letters was to ensure that credit would go to himself first, as Johannes Kepler actually begged Galileo to tell him the unscrambled message, and Galileo refused until Kepler's patron (the Holy Roman Emperor) got into the act too. It was interesting for me to hear about these two sides of Galileo. I was going to also ask him how gene patenting squared with the Bermuda Accords, which were codified into policy by many countries to force scientists to release sequenced genomes into the public domain if said sequences were more than 1000 base pairs long. Unfortunately, there wasn't enough time to ask him that.

(UPDATE: I was also lucky enough to be picked (among about 7-8 other people) to chat with him over lunch today! Yay! Our conversation started with the question of how to get people to truly trust what scientists are telling them, because unless everyone is an expert in every field that gets featured on the news, at some point some level of trust and faith in the verity of what scientists say is unfortunately required. Plus, it's no good if scientists become like fundamentalist preachers standing at the front of the room as a so-called authority dictating how people should think. I think the consensus regarding outreach in this sense is really to start with getting young kids into science, and to plant seeds of curiosity and critical thinking in people in different cities and towns, because people will probably be more open and receptive to scientific ideas if they come from the mouths of their neighbors as opposed to the mouths of outsiders.

The conversation then shifted to other random stuff, including sports, movies, and the recent discovery of neutrinos that travel faster than light through the Earth's innards (but still slower than light in a vacuum). I was able to also ask the question about gene patenting versus the Bermuda Accords, and Dr. Nielsen admitted that his understanding of gene patents was only marginally better than that of a layperson and that he didn't really know what to say about it, aside from the fact that the Accords only seem to apply to sequences of already-existing DNA. Additionally, I asked him how people getting into academia who do not yet have tenure (and the associated very high job security) could practice more open science. He conceded that he really is advocating for more thorough, comprehensive reform on the part of scientists and journals; he reminded me of how yesterday he discussed how only the most cutting-edge (in terms of making the most use of new technologies) journals accept things like YouTube videos, despite the fact that many times, it is almost trivially easy to show in a video what is otherwise almost impossible to clearly write in a paper. He said that individual scientists should publish in open-access journals if said journals exist in the field and if they are of the same quality and have the same quality standards as closed-access counterparts; in addition, if scientists truly believe that things like computer code that they write will be very widely used, they should open that code into the public domain, but asking scientists to open-source everything would be too much and, perhaps, sometimes unwise in and of itself.

The conversations I was able to have with him before and during his colloquium talk and during this lunch were incredibly satisfying and intellectually stimulating, and it makes me so glad that I'm here right now!)
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in glyn moody, Michael Nielsen, open standards, physics, quantum electrodynamics, science | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Long-Term Review: openSUSE 12.2 KDE
    I did this long-term review on my normal UROP desktop computer with the 64-bit edition of the OS. Follow the jump to see how it fared. Also ...
  • How-To: Make Xfce Like Unity
    This is more or less the sequel to this post. It came about because I wanted to see if it would be easy to make Xfce look like Apple's ...
  • SourceForge, Pages, and Respins
    I may have mentioned this in a previous post, but I have added new static pages to this blog. I wanted to mention this again as I will proba...
  • Review: Trisquel 4.0.1 LTS "Taranis"
    Main Screen + Main Menu I've read a couple of reviews of Trisquel GNU/Linux, an Ubuntu-based distribution which aims to remove as much n...
  • Review: Fedora 18 "Spherical Cow" GNOME
    Although I have reviewed a number of Fedora remixes, I haven't reviewed proper Fedora since the very first review/comparison test I post...
  • Review: KDE 4.6
    A couple days ago, KDE 4.6 was released for the world to enjoy. It boasts myriad bug fixes, new features for applications like Dolphin and M...
  • A Disappointing Review of #! 10 "Statler"
    Before I say anything else, I'd just like to say that the reason why I haven't posted anything in 2 weeks has been due to me being q...
  • Review: Linux Mint 14.1 "Nadia" MATE + GNOME 3/Cinnamon
    Wow. It's been a really long time since I've had the time to sit down and do a review like this. The reason for that is because this...
  • Review: Pardus 2013 KDE
    My spring break is coming to an end (I only have 1.5 more days), so I figured it might be nice to do another review while I still can. Today...
  • Review: Slackware 13.1
    KDE Main Screen I never envisioned myself trying out any of the more advanced distributions like Slackware, Arch, or Gentoo, but having trie...

Categories

  • 11
  • 13
  • 1st birthday
  • 200th post
  • 2010
  • 2011
  • 2012
  • 2D
  • 3 Idiots
  • 3D
  • 4
  • 600-series
  • 600C
  • 670C
  • 7
  • 7z
  • 8 glasses every day
  • A Short History of Nearly Everything
  • Abiword
  • abuse of copyright
  • Acer
  • ACTA
  • Activities
  • Adafruit
  • admission
  • Adobe
  • Adobe Flash
  • advertisement
  • Afghanistan
  • agricultural company
  • airport security
  • Albert-Laszlo Barabasi
  • amarok
  • amateur
  • amazon
  • Amy Chua
  • anaconda
  • android
  • AP
  • apology
  • apple
  • applications
  • April fools
  • aptosid
  • Arch
  • ArchBang
  • Arizona
  • asana
  • asthma
  • asus
  • Athena
  • ati
  • ATT
  • AUSTRUMI
  • autofailblog
  • autonomy
  • avatar
  • ayurveda
  • bad experience
  • ban
  • basmati rice
  • Ben Kevan
  • bias
  • Big Bang
  • big brother
  • Bill Bryson
  • biography
  • birthday
  • blackbox
  • blind
  • blog
  • blog catalog
  • Blogger
  • Blogilo
  • Blogspot
  • BMW
  • Bodhi Linux
  • bombing in russia
  • Book Review
  • bootloader
  • boson
  • brand name
  • break
  • breakfast cereal
  • Bridge Linux
  • British Chiropractic Association
  • broadcast
  • browser
  • BSD
  • Burj Khalifa
  • Bursts
  • bus
  • cable
  • calculus
  • cambridge
  • canonical
  • capitalism
  • care
  • Carolus Linnaeus
  • cell
  • cell phone
  • CentOS
  • central planning
  • CGS
  • Chak De India
  • Chakra
  • Chamber of Commerce
  • chat
  • cheese webcam booth
  • chemistry
  • chicken
  • chicken tax
  • china
  • choice
  • choqok
  • Chrome OS
  • Chromium
  • chrysler
  • Cinnamon
  • Cinnarch
  • City ID
  • class
  • codecs
  • coffee
  • college
  • commodore
  • Commonwealth Games
  • comparison
  • compatibility
  • competition
  • compositing
  • conference
  • congress
  • copyright
  • copyright infringement
  • corruption
  • counterfeiting
  • courts
  • Creative Commons
  • crunchbang linux
  • cryptography
  • crystal
  • CSS
  • CTKArchLive
  • custom linux spin
  • CwF + RtB
  • Daniel Craig
  • Das U-Blog by Prashanth
  • DEB
  • debian
  • debt
  • Dedoimedo
  • deficit
  • democrat
  • denial
  • Department of Justice
  • derivative
  • desktop effects
  • Die Another Day
  • disability
  • disappointment
  • disney
  • distribution
  • DMCA
  • DNA
  • dolphin
  • donation
  • dormitory
  • dream
  • DreamWorks
  • driver
  • DRM
  • Dubai
  • dvd
  • earthquake
  • Ease
  • ebook
  • economics
  • Edmunds
  • Edubuntu
  • education
  • educational
  • EFF
  • electricity
  • elementary
  • empathy
  • Enlightenment
  • enzo tedeschi
  • EPDFView
  • epiphany
  • essay
  • Evince
  • exam
  • excitement
  • eye of gnome
  • F-Spot
  • facebook
  • Faenza
  • familiarity
  • family
  • FBI
  • Featured Comments
  • fedora
  • Fedora Core
  • Feedbooks
  • felicia
  • Fermat's Last Theorem
  • Ferris Bueller's Day Off
  • fifa
  • file sharing
  • first
  • First Amendment
  • first sale
  • Fluxbox
  • Folder View
  • FOLLOW-UP
  • football
  • ford
  • free software
  • FreeTechie
  • frequency
  • FreshOS
  • frisk
  • frivolous
  • Fuduntu
  • Fusion
  • future
  • FVWM
  • Gabrielle Giffords
  • Gauss
  • GDM
  • gentoo
  • George Lucas
  • GhostBSD
  • GIMP
  • Gloobus
  • gloria
  • glyn moody
  • gm
  • Gnash
  • gnome
  • GNOME 3
  • GNOME Activities
  • GNOME Shell
  • gnu
  • Gnumeric
  • google
  • Google Docs
  • Gottfried Leibniz
  • government intervention
  • gparted
  • graduation
  • graphics card
  • GRUB
  • gtk+
  • GUI
  • gwenview
  • gwibber
  • Hackers
  • happy new year
  • hardware
  • Harry Potter
  • health
  • heartbeat
  • Higgs
  • high speed rail
  • hollywood
  • homeland security
  • homeless
  • honda
  • How To Train Your Dragon
  • How-To
  • hp
  • HTC
  • HTML
  • i386
  • ibm
  • Ice
  • Iceweasel
  • identity
  • In Defense of Food
  • incentives
  • Inception
  • india
  • Infinite Monkey Theorem
  • Inside Line
  • installation
  • Intel
  • intellectual monopoly
  • intellectual property
  • internet explorer
  • internship
  • Investopedia
  • ipad
  • iphone
  • iphone OS
  • ipod touch
  • Iraq
  • iron man 2
  • Isaac Newton
  • isadora
  • issues
  • ITworld
  • jailbreak
  • James Bond
  • james cameron
  • japanese
  • jill sobule
  • jim lynch
  • jon
  • Julia
  • Julian Assange
  • justice
  • KahelOS
  • Katya
  • KDE
  • kde 3.5
  • KDE 4
  • kde 4.4
  • KDE 4.5
  • KDE 4.6
  • KDE 4.7
  • KDE Activities
  • KevJumba
  • keyboard
  • Kinect
  • KOffice
  • kolourpaint
  • Kongoni
  • konqueror
  • Kopete
  • Kororaa
  • kpackagekit
  • KPresenter
  • kubuntu
  • kwin
  • Lage Raho Munna Bhai
  • laptop
  • last week of school
  • Latvia
  • law
  • lawsuit
  • learning experience
  • LED
  • legal fees
  • lenny
  • Leonard Mlodinow
  • LG
  • liar
  • libel
  • liberal
  • LibreOffice
  • LILO
  • linux
  • linux live cd
  • Linux Mint
  • Linux Today
  • Lisa
  • live cd
  • live dvd
  • live usb
  • long
  • Lubuntu
  • lunatic
  • LXAppearance
  • lxde
  • LXPanel
  • mac
  • mac os x
  • Madbox
  • madurai
  • Mageia
  • mainstream tech press
  • malware
  • mandriva
  • Manjaro Linux
  • marginal cost
  • mark shuttleworth
  • Mark Zuckerberg
  • market
  • market share
  • massacre
  • mastery
  • MATE
  • mathematics
  • Mayans
  • MBodhi Linux
  • mcps
  • meat
  • mebibyte
  • media
  • media companies
  • medicine
  • MEEP
  • Megabus
  • megabyte
  • mepis
  • Metacity
  • metric system
  • MGSE
  • Michael Nielsen
  • Michael Pollan
  • mickey mouse
  • microsoft
  • microsoft office
  • middle
  • Midori
  • misconceptions
  • misrepresentation
  • MIT
  • MLB
  • Mokshagundam
  • money
  • monopoly
  • mouse
  • movie
  • Movie Review
  • Mozilla
  • Mozilla Firefox
  • Mozilla Prism
  • mpaa
  • multiboot
  • MultiSystem
  • MWM
  • national health service
  • national security
  • nautilus
  • NCAA
  • ncurses
  • netbook
  • Netrunner
  • neutrino
  • new computer
  • new york
  • new york city
  • new zealand
  • newbie
  • news corp
  • NFL
  • NHS
  • NIST
  • normal distribution
  • novell
  • numbers
  • nutrition science
  • nutritionism
  • NVidia
  • NZCS
  • obama
  • okular
  • One
  • open standards
  • open-source
  • openbox
  • openoffice.org
  • opensolaris
  • openSUSE
  • Opera
  • oracle
  • Oxidized Trinity
  • P. W. Singer
  • panel
  • paramount
  • Pardus
  • parenting
  • parody
  • particle
  • patent
  • pay-to-pirate
  • PC-BSD
  • pclinuxos
  • pcmanfm
  • Pear OS
  • pearson education
  • Peppermint OS
  • Peter Pan
  • philosophy
  • Photograph 51
  • photonic
  • PHP
  • physics
  • pidgin
  • Pierce Brosnan
  • Pinguy OS
  • pink
  • Pink Floyd
  • piracy
  • plasma
  • plasmoid
  • poll
  • Porteus
  • power
  • power law
  • prejudice
  • presentation
  • president
  • president obama
  • presumption of innocence
  • Princeton
  • printing
  • prisoner
  • privacy
  • profit
  • programming
  • progress
  • Project Natal
  • promotion
  • proprietary
  • public domain
  • purpose
  • qed
  • QEMU
  • qt
  • quantum electrodynamics
  • quantum mechanics
  • radio
  • rape
  • Rawhide
  • Razor-Qt
  • red hat
  • Reflection
  • Rekonq
  • religion
  • Remastersys
  • rent
  • repossession
  • republican
  • retroactive copyright
  • review
  • rewards
  • RHEL
  • RIAA
  • Righthaven
  • RMA
  • robotics
  • rolling release
  • rootkit
  • ROSA
  • royalty
  • RPM
  • RSS
  • rule
  • rupert murdoch
  • sabayon
  • safari
  • saints
  • Salix OS
  • Samsung
  • sarah palin
  • Saudi Arabia
  • scanner
  • school
  • school network
  • science
  • Scientific Linux
  • security theater
  • selection
  • semester
  • Semplice
  • senior
  • Shiki
  • shooting
  • Shotwell
  • shut down
  • SI
  • sidux
  • Simon Singh
  • simplymepis
  • Skype
  • skyscraper
  • Slackware
  • slander
  • slashdot
  • social media
  • social policy
  • socialism
  • software patents
  • solar
  • SolusOS
  • SolydXK
  • sony
  • sony-bmg
  • SOPA
  • Source Code
  • SourceForge
  • SPARC
  • special effects
  • spying
  • spyware
  • Squeeze
  • SSH
  • Star Wars
  • State Department
  • statin
  • statistical mechanics
  • Statler
  • Stella
  • steve jobs
  • stewart
  • Stuxnet
  • subscriber
  • subsidy
  • substitute
  • sun
  • Sun Tzu
  • super bowl
  • Super Bowl XLV
  • super user
  • Suresh Kalmadi
  • survey
  • Symbicort
  • synaptic
  • tablet
  • Talledega Nights
  • tax
  • tech company
  • Tech Drive-in
  • techdirt
  • Technorati
  • Ted Williams
  • terrorist
  • thanksgiving
  • The Adjustment Bureau
  • The Amazing Race
  • The Art of War
  • The Code Book
  • The Drunkard's Walk
  • The King's Speech
  • The Social Network
  • the tunnel
  • the undercover economist
  • thermophotovoltaic
  • thunar
  • tim
  • Tim Harford
  • tint2
  • torrent
  • Toy Story 3
  • toyota
  • tracking device
  • trademark
  • train
  • treason
  • Trinity
  • Trisquel
  • trivial
  • troll
  • TSA
  • TuxMachines
  • Twitter
  • TWM
  • UberBang
  • ubuntu
  • ubuntu one
  • UK
  • unetbootin
  • unintended acceleration
  • units
  • Unity
  • Unixoid Review
  • UROP
  • US
  • utopia
  • V. S. Narayana Rao
  • VectorLinux
  • vegan
  • vegetarian
  • Verizon
  • vesa
  • Viewnior
  • ViewPad
  • ViewSonic
  • violation
  • virtual desktop
  • VirtualBox
  • virus
  • Visvesvaraya
  • vlc
  • warfare
  • water
  • WattOS
  • wavelength
  • Wayland
  • web-connected printer
  • webcam
  • WebOS
  • weekly
  • whistle
  • widget
  • wifi
  • wiki
  • Wikileaks
  • William Shakespeare
  • windowing system
  • WindowMaker
  • windows
  • windows 7
  • windows vista
  • windows xp
  • Wired for War
  • word
  • WordPress
  • world cup
  • Wubi
  • x11
  • XBMC
  • xbox360
  • xfce
  • xkcd
  • xp
  • yahoo
  • yoga
  • YouTube
  • YSA
  • Zenwalk
  • Zorin OS

Blog Archive

  • ►  2013 (63)
    • ►  September (4)
    • ►  August (9)
    • ►  July (3)
    • ►  June (9)
    • ►  May (7)
    • ►  April (10)
    • ►  March (11)
    • ►  February (6)
    • ►  January (4)
  • ►  2012 (85)
    • ►  December (4)
    • ►  November (3)
    • ►  October (2)
    • ►  September (6)
    • ►  August (8)
    • ►  July (12)
    • ►  June (12)
    • ►  May (7)
    • ►  April (6)
    • ►  March (6)
    • ►  February (9)
    • ►  January (10)
  • ▼  2011 (179)
    • ►  December (5)
    • ►  November (8)
    • ►  October (9)
    • ▼  September (12)
      • So ACTA's Getting Passed After All
      • The Neutrino News and Science in the Public
      • Featured Comments: Week of 2011 September 18
      • I Met Michael Nielsen!
      • Review: Linux Mint GNOME 201109
      • Star Wars and George Lucas's Overreach
      • Featured Comments: Week of 2011 September 11
      • Revisited: Fuduntu 14.10.1
      • First UROP: Thermophotovoltaics
      • Third Semester at College
      • Featured Comments: Week of 2011 August 28
      • Reflection: 2011 Summer
    • ►  August (15)
    • ►  July (15)
    • ►  June (15)
    • ►  May (16)
    • ►  April (15)
    • ►  March (19)
    • ►  February (21)
    • ►  January (29)
  • ►  2010 (173)
    • ►  December (24)
    • ►  November (23)
    • ►  October (34)
    • ►  September (36)
    • ►  August (15)
    • ►  July (18)
    • ►  June (13)
    • ►  May (8)
    • ►  April (2)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile